The Employment Value of Higher Education

As of June, California’s unemployment rate was 5.4%, the lowest that it’s been in nearly nine years. Of course, in that nine years, California’s workers have seen drastic swings in employment opportunity. Higher education is a key determinant of how people fare when the economy slows.

Californians with education credentials beyond high school, from an associate’s degree up to a doctoral degree, have lower than average unemployment rates in general – and had smaller spikes in unemployment during the recession. Even workers with just some schooling beyond high school, but less than an associate’s or bachelor’s degree, fare systematically better than those without any college experience. The following figure shows how unemployment varied according to education levels since 2008. These estimates rely on detailed Census Bureau survey data, which is produced with a significant lag, so the most recent information we have pertains to calendar year 2014.

Although employment across all categories has recovered to its pre-recession levels (or nearly so), Californians with more education have had a smoother course. Unemployment among workers without a post-secondary degree jumped 5–7 points during the recession, but increased by only 2 points for those with advanced degrees.

In good times and in bad, the likelihood of employment is higher the more education Californians have. This—along with generally higher wages—contributes to the substantial gain in lifetime earnings for those who obtain post-secondary credentials. Despite widespread discussion about the value of a college education, the lifetime economic opportunity afforded by post-secondary credentials is not up for debate.

Chart source: Author calculations from American Community Survey data, age 25 and older.

Learn more

Will California Run out of College Graduates?
California’s Need for Skilled Workers
Student Debt and the Value of a College Degree

Poverty and Well-being in California

California is one of 12 states in which poverty declined last year, according to newly released US Census statistics. The state’s official poverty rate is down by 0.6 percentage points to 16.4%, from 17.0% in 2012. But poverty in the state remains high relative to the early 2000s. In 2007, the year the Great Recession began, California’s official poverty rate was 12.4%.

Official poverty statistics are intended to capture cash resources at hand. In other research we have analyzed the role of social safety net programs in augmenting cash resources and helping families to avoid dire economic need.

It’s important to note that jobs are still the biggest source of income for Californians overall, even among those living in poverty. And good news out last week shows the economy is continuing to improve—the unemployment rate in California is now 6.1%, less than half of what it was during the worst of the economic crisis.

At the same time we are all aware that well-being is complex, so it is instructive to look at multiple measures. Food insecurity—defined as ranging from worrying about being able to afford enough food to actually cutting back on meals—is also down from a recent high of 16.2% in California (across 2009–2011) and is estimated to be 13.5% for 2012–2014. In addition, the number of homeless in California—often not well-represented in indicators of need—is estimated to have declined by 13% between 2012 and 2014. The share of all California children with a validated report of maltreatment (most commonly for reasons of neglect) has also dropped, although this appears to be a longer term trend that predates the recession.

Broadly speaking, then, trends in well-being appear to be positive, even though we have a ways to go before poverty and other indicators decline to the levels experienced before the recession.

High Poverty Rate Persists

Although the state’s economy has rebounded, the latest poverty statistics suggest there’s been little improvement in the share of Californians struggling to make ends meet.

More than 1 in 5 Californians—or 8.1 million people—were living in poverty in 2012, the most recent year for which we have data. This is according to the California Poverty Measure, a comprehensive metric developed by PPIC and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality. This share is about the same as it was in 2011. Rates were highest among children, with about 1 in 4, or 2.3 million, living in poverty—virtually unchanged from 2011.

Why? Although California’s overall economy is growing, not all have shared equally in the recovery. The reasons for this are both specific to this economic recovery and true more generally of economic upturns. The unemployment rate remains higher than it has been since 2004 and a high share of workers—by historical standards—have given up looking for work or are underemployed (working part time when they would prefer full time, for example). As is typical of past patterns of recession and recovery, high-income families tend to rebound most quickly, followed by middle-income and finally low- income families. This means that improvements in poverty metrics tend to lag behind other indicators of how the economy is faring.

The good news is that the social safety net—programs like CalFresh and the federal Earned Income Tax Credit—helped many families through the recession and still plays an important role in keeping families out of poverty. Without it, more families—including 1.3 million children—would be poor. We estimated that without these and other safety net programs, poverty would be roughly a third higher in the state as a whole. This cushioning effect of the safety net decreases swings in poverty, meaning that a slowly changing poverty rate is partly an indication that the safety net is working.

What the Unemployment Rate Doesn’t Show Us

California’s unemployment rate is 7.2%, down from 8.4% one year ago and from California’s peak of 12.4% in 2010. California is adding jobs faster than the nation as a whole and now has more jobs than before the recession. Also, the ratio of employment to population is slowly increasing, a sign that more people are reentering the labor force. However, behind these oft-cited statistics, the picture is more complicated.

While California’s economy is improving, the recovery has not been strong or fast enough to keep up with the growth in California’s working-age population. Additionally, the recovery has been uneven across sectors and metro areas, and the unemployment rate is still higher than it was before the recession began. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, California has the third-highest unemployment rate in the nation—only Mississippi and the District of Columbia have higher rates. In numerical terms, 1.35 million Californians are looking for work—and more than 35% of them have been looking for at least six months.

High as it is, the unemployment rate does not account for the 7% of California adults who are underemployed—working part-time when they’d rather work full-time. Nor does it count “discouraged and marginally attached” workers—those who have stopped looking for work because, for example, they think there are no jobs available or they don’t have the skills for available jobs. When discouraged and underemployed workers are added to the ranks of unemployed, California’s rate of un- and underemployment (or labor underutilization,” the term used by the Bureau of Labor Statistics) comes to 15.4%—8.2 points higher than the official unemployment rate. In fact, California’s underutilization rate is the second highest in the country (only Nevada’s is higher). Based on underemployment rates, we know that growth is needed not just in the number of jobs but also the number of full-time jobs.

Education is the most important factor in determining who is employed—and fully employed. Workers with college degrees are less likely to be unemployed, underemployed, or to have stopped looking for work. These workers fared better during the recession, an indication that education can be a buffer against the bust cycles of our economy. And education is likely to be increasingly relevant in our future economy: more than two-thirds of new jobs over the next 10 years or so will require at least some college training.

State and federal policymakers are making some investments in training resources for California’s workforce—the California Career Pathways Trust and the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act are two good examples. The challenge is to do more to ensure that current and future workers are trained for the jobs of both today and tomorrow.